“The more You Preach, the Fewer You Reach” – Is the title of an Interview Christianity Today did with Veggie Tales creator and Big Idea Productions founder and owner Phil Vischer. The title is direct quote from Vischer in the interview.
In the interview Vischer address’s some very key issues facing Christian movies and their makers. I think it hit’s the nail on the head with some of his points. In particular interest was his reasoning on why movies like Passion, Narnia and LOTR were successful as opposed to movies like Evan Almighty and The Nativity. I agree with him in that he (and others) have observed that if a movie is made which has a distinct Christian message to it or is a retelling of a Biblical story – accuracy and not artistic license is more than favored but demanded. The other interesting observation was that LOTR and Narnia got the OK by Christians and the World because the story is set in complete allegory with no direct religious reference’s. Now what does that mean we should do practically? I’m not sure.
The other very interesting observation he made was this.
Now, if we go to another fantasy world, we need to find Jesus there—literally. That is why the Harry Potter books are viewed to be straight from the pit. Even if Rowling says she’s enjoying Christian themes, forget it. How do you write a Christian fantasy today? I have no idea. I don’t know that you can. I think we’ve killed it. I think we are so concerned with how oppressed our worldview is and so defensive that we’ve painted ourselves into a corner. And thus, we can’t tell the kind of stories that Lewis or Chesterton would have told to share the gospel. It’s kind of depressing, frankly. – PVicsher
I’m not sure how to get my head around this one. Could a Christian fantasy movie be made today? or What about a Christian Sci-Fi? Could you make the movie Transformers from a Christian worldview? Can we write Christian fiction with fantastical non Christian specific elements that didn’t raise an eyebrow? Could you write fiction about the end of the world which is opposed to the Bible(Like just about every apocalyptic movie), even though its fiction? Does a Christian allegory have to be set in an unreal fantasy world? What about movies like the Matrix which is heavily ladened with Christian Themes. Could that be written and reproduced by a Christian Studio and be accepted by the Christian audience? What if movies are made to parallel Jesus parables or his Teachings? How indirect can the story be and still be ‘Christian’.
Its funny to think, Narnia is a very Christian movie if your a Christian. But it also is not a Christian movie at all. There’s no direct reference to a specific Christian only element. It could be argued that all themes can be found from other reference points and all the Witchcraft – magic etc Is quite UnChristian.
Something to think about, just not for too long. It really isn’t that important but the answers to these questions do have bearing in more areas of the Christian life than entertainment.
Posted in Christianity, Faith, Jesus Christ, Movies, Religion, Religious Tolerance, Truth War
Tags: Animation, Christian Movies, Entertainment, Film making, Interviews, Movies